Rhinoceros

How Consumers Energy's $43 Million Dark Money Operation Reaches Lansing City Hall

March 25, 2026

-- Between 2014 and 2017, Consumers Energy funneled $43.5 million into a single anonymous nonprofit called Citizens for Energizing Michigan's Economy (CEME, EIN 46-4355362). In 2022, CEME gave $200,000 to an organization whose legal agent is the same attorney who manages a network of anonymous political nonprofits, a sitting judge's former infrastructure, and the personal holding company of Lansing's most connected political consultant.

The connection, documented on IRS tax filings and Michigan corporate records, links Michigan's largest electric utility to the political network that shapes who holds power in Lansing and how that power is exercised.


What Is a 501(c)(4) and Why Does It Matter Here?

A 501(c)(4) is an IRS designation for a "social welfare" nonprofit. In practice, these organizations are the primary vehicle for anonymous political spending in American politics. They have three features that make them attractive for political operatives:

  1. No donor disclosure. Unlike PACs or campaign committees, 501(c)(4) organizations are not required to publicly report who gives them money. Donors remain anonymous.
  2. Unlimited corporate money. Corporations can give unlimited amounts. There are no contribution limits.
  3. Political spending is allowed up to approximately 40% of the organization's budget, including TV ads, mailers, and polling.

In Michigan, 501(c)(4)s have an additional advantage that does not exist at the federal level: state law permits coordination between these anonymous nonprofits and candidates in state and local elections. A 501(c)(4) funded by anonymous corporate money can legally coordinate its messaging, strategy, and spending with a Lansing mayoral campaign or a city council candidate.

Reid Felsing, the attorney at the center of this network who is now a sitting judge on the Eaton County 56A District Court (appointed by Governor Whitmer, effective January 6, 2025), explained exactly how this works on a 2019 podcast produced by Grassroots Midwest, the consulting firm at the center of the Lansing network:

"The beauty of the C4 is the anonymity of money coming in. There's plausible deniability... all you know is the name of the C4 and the name of the directors."

Reid Felsing, TicketSplitters Episode 10, May 29, 2019

"That's the key thing of the C4 is getting that corporate dollars and especially if the corporation wants to give money and not have people or not get backlash from people that aren't exactly on board with that particular issue, that's a double win for them. They can get the money into that issue and they don't face the business consequences of it."

Reid Felsing, same episode

Adrian Hemond, CEO of Grassroots Midwest, endorsed Felsing's services on the same episode: "We use Reed for some of this type of work on behalf of our clients. And he does a really stellar job with it."

Eighteen months after this podcast aired, Felsing organized Hemond's personal holding company. That holding company is now managed by the same attorney who manages Felsing's network of anonymous nonprofits. The same network that receives money from Michigan's largest utility.


How Utility Money Reaches Lansing City Hall Every connection sourced from IRS 990s, FEC filings, LARA records, and MiTN campaign finance data CONSUMERS ENERGY Michigan's largest electric utility GCSI (Lobbying Firm) MI #1 · Represents Consumers · CEO's wife = LARA Dir. Lobbying client $43M+ CEME Citizens for Energizing Michigan's Economy 501(c)(4) · $12.6M war chest · Run by former Consumers lobbyist $200,000 CITIZENS FOR A BETTER MICHIGAN 501(c)(4) · Agent: Jack Rucker · Address: Felsing's home Part of the 428 W Lenawee dark money network (10+ orgs) ⚖ JUDGE FELSING Eaton County 56A District Court Built the dark money network Still agent for one C4 (14 mo. on bench) $205K SUPER PAC "The Moderate Michigan Voice" Felsing: treasurer ($5K paid) · $199K TV ads Zero disclosure at FEC, MI SOS, and FCC Treasurer Organized holding co. ADRIAN HEMOND CEO, Grassroots Midwest TV "analyst" on PBS, Bridge, WDET (no client disclosure) Trained Hemond (5 years, 2007-12) GRASSROOTS MIDWEST $3.24M from 77 committees · Advises ALL sides 110 W Lenawee, Lansing CEO of $205K MAYOR SCHOR $229K to GM (3 entities) LOCAL 333 $203K to GM · Union PAC CHAMBER PAC $32K to GM · LRC-PAC $112K LANSING CITY COUNCIL 7 of 8 members funded by Chamber PAC or Local 333 Ryan Kost (Ward 1) is the only exception: $0 from either source $104K $26K ↓ Votes on zoning, development, contracts, and policy DTE ENERGY MI's 2nd utility · PAC $ → Felsing clients $31K treasurer fees Sources: IRS 990 (EIN 46-4355362, Schedule I), FEC (C00825901), LARA (802764120, 802559806), MiTN (507652, 000516), Ingham County EasyVote, SoundCloud (TicketSplitters Ep. 10 & 13) Utility / dark money Felsing network Judge Felsing Grassroots Midwest Political actors Council
How utility money reaches Lansing City Hall. Every arrow is documented in public records: IRS 990 filings, FEC filings, LARA corporate records, MiTN campaign finance data. Sources listed at bottom of diagram.

The Money Trail: Consumers Energy to Lansing

Step 1: Consumers Energy to CEME ($43.5 Million)

Consumers Energy is Michigan's largest electric utility, a subsidiary of CMS Energy Corporation. It serves 1.8 million electric customers and 1.7 million natural gas customers across Michigan's Lower Peninsula.

Between 2014 and 2017, Consumers Energy gave $43.5 million to Citizens for Energizing Michigan's Economy (CEME), a 501(c)(4) run by Howard J. Edelson, a former Consumers Energy lobbyist, at 2145 Commons Parkway, Okemos, Michigan. CEME used this money to run political attack ads, fund lobbying ($1.4 million in 2022 alone), and make grants to other anonymous nonprofits. None of this spending disclosed that the money came from a utility company funded by ratepayers.

In 2019, Consumers Energy agreed to stop making dark money donations for two years as part of a Michigan Public Service Commission rate settlement. But CEME retained $12.6 million in assets as of the end of 2022 and continued spending $4.5 million that year alone.

Step 2: CEME to the Felsing Network ($200,000)

CEME's 2022 IRS 990 (Schedule I, "Grants to Domestic Organizations") itemizes four grants totaling $450,000. The largest: $200,000 to Citizens for a Better Michigan (EIN 87-3528832), described as a "Social Welfare Contribution."

Citizens for a Better Michigan is not an independent organization. According to Michigan LARA corporate records (Entity 802764120):

Jack Rucker is a 2022 law school graduate who inherited Felsing's law practice when Felsing was appointed to the bench. Rucker manages the same portfolio of organizations Felsing built: at least eight 501(c)(4) nonprofits and PACs operating from 428 W Lenawee Street in Lansing. All share a phone number (517-885-2000), an accountant (Riverside Accounting Inc, Grand Ledge, Michigan), and a rotating officer pattern with the same three names.

Among the entities Rucker manages: Adrian Hemond Holding LLC (LARA 802559806), the personal holding company of the CEO of Grassroots Midwest. Felsing organized that holding company on November 20, 2020. It was originally registered at Felsing's home address before being transferred to Rucker's office.

The other three CEME grants went to:

Step 3: The Felsing Network to Grassroots Midwest

The Felsing network connects to Lansing's most influential political consulting firm through five documented links:

  1. Personal relationship. Hemond was Felsing's instructor at Saginaw Valley State University, predating both men's professional careers.
  2. Professional relationship. Hemond confirmed on the 2019 podcast that Grassroots Midwest uses Felsing for "this type of work" on behalf of clients.
  3. Corporate integration. Felsing organized Hemond's personal holding company (November 2020). The holding company is now managed by the same attorney (Rucker) who manages the entity that received the $200,000 Consumers Energy grant.
  4. Super PAC operation. In October 2022, Grassroots Midwest created a federal Super PAC called "The Moderate Michigan Voice" (FEC C00825901) and sole-funded it with $205,000. Reid Felsing signed the FEC financial filing as treasurer and was paid $5,000 for "Treasurer service." The PAC spent $198,599 on cable television ads through Effectv (Comcast's advertising platform) one week before the November 2022 midterm election, then terminated four months later. All spending was classified as "Non-Federal" on the FEC filing, avoiding standard Super PAC disclosure requirements. No filing was made with the Michigan Secretary of State despite the non-federal classification. The FCC political file for the Comcast cable system serving Lansing contains a folder labeled "MODERATE MICHIGAN VOICE" under Local, Lansing, Unknown, but the folder is empty.
  5. Continuing ties. As of March 17, 2026, Felsing remains the named resident agent for Michigan Alliance for Progress (LARA 803202489), a 501(c)(4) at 428 W Lenawee Street, 14 months after taking the judicial bench.

Step 4: Grassroots Midwest to Lansing Politics

Grassroots Midwest Inc. (LARA 800767416) is a Lansing-based political consulting firm that has received $3.24 million from 77 political committees at the federal, state, and local levels. It simultaneously advises:

Grassroots Midwest's CEO, Adrian Hemond, appears regularly on PBS (WKAR), Bridge Michigan, Michigan Advance, and WDET as a political analyst and commentator. He does not disclose that he simultaneously consults for the mayor, the union, and the Chamber PAC.

Seven of eight current Lansing City Council members receive funding from either the Chamber PAC, Local 333, or both:

Council MemberSeatChamber PACLocal 333Combined
Jeremy GarzaAt-Large$1,000$74,500$75,500
Peter SpadaforeWard 4 (President)$6,500$13,000$19,500
Tamera CarterAt-Large$9,850$5,000$14,850
Trini PehlivanogluAt-Large (VP)$7,900$2,500$10,400
Clara MartinezAt-Large$4,000$5,000$9,000
Adam HussainWard 2--$4,000$4,000
Deyanira Nevarez MartinezWard 3$1,500--$1,500
Ryan KostWard 1----$0

Sources: Ingham County EasyVote portal, MiTN. Chamber PAC: 6 of 8 funded. Local 333: 6 of 8 funded. Either source: 7 of 8. Ryan Kost is the only council member with zero funding from either source.


The Lobbying Connection

There is one more link. GCSI (Governmental Consultant Services Inc.) is Michigan's top-ranked multi-client lobbying firm: 120+ clients, $1.4 million per year in lobbying expenditures, voted "most effective" for 20 consecutive years. GCSI represents Consumers Energy as a lobbying client.

Adrian Hemond worked at GCSI from 2007 to 2012 as an associate lobbyist. He left to become Chief of Staff to House Minority Leader Tim Greimel, then founded Grassroots Midwest in 2013.

GCSI's CEO, Mike Hawks, is married to Orlene Hawks, who served as Director of LARA (Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs) from 2019 to 2023 under Governor Whitmer. LARA is the state agency that oversees all Michigan corporate filings, including the formation, annual reports, and agent changes for every entity in the Felsing network.

GCSI also donated $2,500 as a corporate entity to the Schor Lansing Fund (the mayor's 527 political organization) across four donations from 2020 to 2024.


The Loop

Utility ratepayers pay their electric bills. Consumers Energy collects the revenue. $43.5 million goes to an anonymous nonprofit run by a former Consumers lobbyist. That nonprofit gives $200,000 to another anonymous nonprofit whose legal agent manages the personal holding company of the CEO of the consulting firm that simultaneously advises the mayor, the union, and the Chamber PAC that together fund 7 of 8 city council members. Those council members vote on zoning, development, contracts, and policy that affects every resident of the city.

Meanwhile, the lobbying firm that represents Consumers Energy trained the consulting firm's CEO for five years. The lobbying firm's CEO's wife ran the state agency that oversees the corporate filings for the entire anonymous nonprofit network. The attorney who built the network and organized the consulting firm CEO's holding company was appointed to the bench by the governor, and he remains listed as the legal agent for one of his political nonprofits 14 months after becoming a judge.

Every connection described in this article is documented in public records: IRS 990 filings, FEC filings, Michigan LARA corporate records, MiTN campaign finance data, Ingham County campaign finance records, and a podcast transcript. The records are spread across five different databases maintained by four different agencies. Nobody had assembled them into one picture until now.


Sources

ClaimSource
Consumers Energy gave $43M+ to CEMEMichigan Public Radio (Jan 29, 2019)
CEME gave $200K to Citizens for a Better MichiganCEME IRS 990 Schedule I (FY 2022)
Citizens for a Better Michigan agent is Jack RuckerLARA Entity 802764120
Address on IRS filing is 105 W Hillsdale (Felsing's)CEME IRS 990 Schedule I
Felsing organized Hemond Holding LLCLARA Entity 802559806
Felsing was paid $5K as Super PAC treasurerFEC F3X filing, C00825901 (page 7)
$198,599 to Effectv for TV adsSame FEC filing, Schedule H4
GM received $3.24M from 77 committeesMiTN, FEC, county portal
GCSI represents Consumers EnergyCrain's Detroit Business
Hemond worked at GCSI 2007-2012grassrootsmidwest.com
Orlene Hawks was LARA Director 2019-2023Multiple news sources
Felsing still agent for MI Alliance for ProgressLARA Entity 803202489 (verified March 17, 2026)
Podcast quotes (Felsing, Hemond, Japinga)SoundCloud: TicketSplitters Episodes 10 and 13
Council member fundingIngham County EasyVote, MiTN
MCFR gave $250K to Great Lakes Jobs AllianceDetroit News (Dec 14, 2021)
Paul Cordes was MI GOP Chief of StaffWZZM13